geek
We're trying to reach 3000 New Supporters by the end of 2008!
BoardGameGeek Supporter Drive
300 600 900 1200 1500 1800 2100 2400 2700 3000 3300
   
629 New Supporters - Support BGG Now!
Recently Viewed
Hot Games
Dominion
Agricola
Axis & Allies Anniversary Edition
Battlestar Galactica
Pandemic
Android
Lost Cities: The Board Game
Settlers of Catan, The
Race for the Galaxy
Le Havre
Puerto Rico
Wasabi!
Power Grid
Ghost Stories
Sorry! Sliders
Titan
Arkham Horror
Apples to Apples
Carcassonne
Conflict of Heroes: Awakening the Bear! - Russia 1941-1942
Twilight Struggle
Through the Ages: A Story of Civilization
Red November
Ticket to Ride
War of the Ring
Stone Age
Descent: Journeys in the Dark
Tigris & Euphrates
Risk
Last Night on Earth: The Zombie Game
Galaxy Trucker
Space Alert
A Touch of Evil, The Supernatural Game
BattleLore
Caylus
Race for the Galaxy: The Gathering Storm
Age of Conan: The Strategy Board Game
Formula D
Munchkin Quest
Scrabble
El Grande
Guess Who
World of WarCraft Miniatures Game
StarCraft: The Board Game
Age of Empires III: The Age of Discovery
Railroad Tycoon
Twilight Imperium 3rd Edition
Mad Gab
Exalted: War for the Throne
Monster Mayhem
Rules | Subscriptions | Bookmarks | Search | Account | Moderators
Recommend
49
25 Posts
New Thread | Printer Friendly | Subscribe | Bookmark
Your Tags: Login to Add Tags | View 
Popular Tags: [View All]
Don Clarke
flag
Avatar
The skinny version? Rejoice! This is a great expansion.

In a little more detail, the Memoir 44 community over on the Days of Wonder forums have long requested this expansion, primarily via a thread with 381 posts and 33648 views (and still rising, amazingly!), and at last the Brits are here. The expansion brings us new national characteristic rules for the British and Commonwealth and Italian armies, new terrain types, additional tiles of established terrain types, new North Africa scenarios, and a whole new category of unit: the Special Weapon Asset.

The Special Weapon Asset, in this expansion an 'anti-tank gun' asset represented by a panzershreck mini (called bazooka in the expansion rulebook), plays beautifully. You simply embed the mini within a standard infantry unit, a concept introduced first in Battlelore, and the asset provides the unit with additional capability. I tend to think of the unit as a standard infantry unit but with additional AT support elements. This impacts mobility, hence no taking ground if you're lugging around anti-tank weapons. Panzershrecks weren't used in North Africa, but the mini is representative of all manner of anti-tank weapons and so allowing a little poetic license is appropriate.

Regarding the British infantry mini, it's great to see the desert uniform. The mini looks good, although I think the helmet looks like a mark III 'turtle' helmet, which was actually a '44 helmet type. I'd have preferred the famous mark II with the wide brim - but how nit-picky is that! In any case, when the figures arrive they may look more like mark IIs than they do in the picture. The Crusader and the 25pdr minis are both mouth-watering, although it was recently pointed out that the Crusader mini has 6 bogie wheels rather than the 5 it should have. It's a small issue since the rest of the tank looks excellent, and the number of bogies will be unnoticed in play.

The Stiff Upper Lip rule is cool, giving the Brits a 1 die battleback if they're down to their last figure and not pushed back in close combat. Other characteristics of the wartime British Army - donkyish leadership and brewing tea at inappropriate times, like in combat situations (see Villers-Bocage) - can be assumed to be built into the British command card allocation.

The Italian national rules are great, and the Motorised Divisions rule allowing Italian units to retreat 1, 2, or 3 hexes for each flag taken is simply a stroke of genius. Whoever it was at DoW that came up with that one deserves some kind of award. How do you meld the popular (not in Italy) perception of Italian troops having brittle morale and running at the drop of a mark II helmet, with the reality of a brave and determined bunch of guys who were poorly armed and poorly led? How about the Royal Italian Army Motorised Rule? Sublime.

The Airpack isn't used in this expansion. Perhaps air power wasn't decisive in these battles, but there were aircraft available to both sides over the course of the campaigns covered. After playing the scenarios as intended, players missing the familiar drone of the Merlin might want to take an Air Sortie card each at the start of a battle.

Barry Kendall
flag
Game Designer
Oh my gosh, it's true, the Crusader has six road wheels. It looks like the bottom of a Centurion.

At least the tank has sand skirts, and the topside isn't bad--distinctive angled-armor turret--but the driver's compartment is very oversized (this is probably a consequence of the length distortion caused by that sixth road wheel). Nonetheless, a recognizable British tank with good flavor for the Desert War and a much better choice than Matilda, Churchill or a rehashed Sherman.

The 25 pdr is correctly shown on its circular pivoting base.

The Tommie does indeed have an odd-looking helmet. I'm betting that will be the production piece. Nice wool socks, though, and a classic pose.

The AT asset is a curious miniature--weapon, no crew. Wonder if the British AT piece is the same bit in tan, or something different? (What would it be--surely not a PIAT?)

The far-more-generous-than-usual DoW preview for this module is a welcome sharing of information. I hope it presages a new era of "glasnost" for DoW's pre-publication information.

Really looking forward to armor fights in the desert!
Kevin Reynolds
flag
07
Since the AT asset is "manned" when its placed with infantry units, it actually makes sense not to have it depicted with a unit on it. Also, I believe that the AT asset won't be considered part of any nations unit, but a unit that is interchangeable with any nationality in the game. I bet it remains grey.
Rory
flag
Avatar
A review when it looks like you haven't even played the game yet? :what:
Don Clarke
flag
Avatar
I'd never review a game I hadn't played. In fairness I've played some but not all of the scenarios, and it's the first I've seen of the Italian national rules, but I think my review doesn't mislead in that respect. The rest I'm very familiar with :)
Don Clarke
flag
Avatar
I forgot to mention the wool socks, Barry. I SO love the wool socks :D
Christopher Taylor
flag
Game Designer
Avatar
05060708
Is this shipping already?
Don Clarke
flag
Avatar
It's on pre-order Chris, but the rules and scenarios are up on the DoW website and freely downloadable, and the wooly socks are clearly evident.
Rick Teverbaugh
flag
roboman wrote:
A review when it looks like you haven't even played the game yet? :what:


Does this really look like a review to you? It looks to me like a detailed and informed story about the expansion. Since it is an expansion to a game that has been often played by many people, I believe the detail in this story is warranted and can be believed.
Christopher Taylor
flag
Game Designer
Avatar
05060708
yangtze2000 wrote:
It's on pre-order Chris, but the rules and scenarios are up on the DoW website and freely downloadable,


Excellent! Thanks, I'll have to check them out!

yangtze2000 wrote:
and the wooly socks are clearly evident.


One can never have enough wooly socks.
Kevin Reynolds
flag
07
rickert wrote:
roboman wrote:
A review when it looks like you haven't even played the game yet? :what:


Does this really look like a review to you? It looks to me like a detailed and informed story about the expansion. Since it is an expansion to a game that has been often played by many people, I believe the detail in this story is warranted and can be believed.


I think its because its in the "Review" section of the forum.
Rick Teverbaugh
flag
I guess that's OK for people who only read labels.:laugh:
Don Clarke
flag
Avatar
Do you notice I'm keeping a stiff upper lip about all of this? ;)
Barry Ingram
flag
Avatar
Hey - tough crowd!!

Nice synopsis Yangtze.
Maybe we can rustle up some serious hot-desert actions [oo-er] at next year's Expo tourney (Hay Festival permitting, of course).
2
<